Terra Nova Alone Together in World of Warcraft
Terra Nova A weblog about virtual worlds. Meta Data About TN
Search TN Archives
Where in meatspace are we?
Comment Policy
Recent Comments Chris on Fortitude, Save Games, and the MMO Richard on Fortitude, Save Games, and the MMO Edward Castronova on Fortitude, Save Games, and the MMO Tripp on Fortitude, Save Games, and the MMO Verilazic on Fortitude, Save Games, and the MMO Lydia Laurenson on Fortitude, Save Games, and the MMO gazarsgo on I want to fall in love again greglas on Fortitude, Save Games, and the MMO Mat Kaz on Fortitude, Save Games, and the MMO Chris Proctor on Fortitude, Save Games, and the MMO Archives January 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009
More…
Categories Academia Blatant Self-Promotion Books Design Economics Funny Games greglas Law Lisa G News News and Olds Opinion Philosophy & Ethics Policy Politics Psychology and Culture Public Statements Random Security Sociology Technology Trends Web/Tech Some Virtual Worlds A Tale in the Desert Achaea Active Worlds City of Heroes Club Penguin Counter-Strike Dark Age of Camelot Dark Ages Dubit EVE EverQuest EverQuest II Final Fantasy XI Furcadia Gaia online Habbo Hotel Iron Realms Kaneva Kingdom of Loathing Kingdom of the Winds LambdaMOO Legend of Mir Lineage Lineage II Mabinogi Matrix Online Meridian 59 MU Online Multiverse Neopets Neverwinter Nights Play.net Playd Project Darkstar Project Entropia Project Outback Ragnarok Online Runescape Ryzom Second Life Seed Shadowbane Skotos Star Wars Galaxies The Sims Online There ToonTown Ultima Online Vanguard Vzones Webkinz Whyville World of Warcraft Yohoho! Puzzle Pirates
« Welcome to Nic Ducheneaut | Main | Pharaoh’s Expectations »
"Alone Together" in World of Warcraft?
The "social factor" is often advanced to explain the popularity of MMOs: "it’s the people that are addictive, not the game." And indeed, social networks are essential components of the online gaming experience. Game designers build "virtual third places" to encourage interactions. Quality time in a MMO is time spent with others, be it raiding a dungeon in a group, socializing with bystanders in a cantina, or chatting with remote guildmates while exploring the wilderness on your own.
Or… is it? The data PlayOn has assembled from World of Warcraft challenges many of these assumptions. Could it be that a less, not more, social environment contributed to WoW’s success? Read on for more.
For the past 8 months, we have been collecting and analyzing data from WoW. We use "bots" on 5 different servers (covering PvP, PvE and RP realms) and take snapshots of the population every 10 minutes or so (more detail here), capturing data about each present character’s level, location, grouped status, and guild affiliation (among other things). So far,www.forwowgold.org, we have observed about 150,000 unique characters. While this data is far from perfect (after all, we are only getting what Blizzard is willing to let transpire through their API), it can still yield a surprising amount of insight into the social dimensions of multiplayer games.
We have tried to assess the prevalence of social activities in WoW using a variety of metrics. The most obvious is the time players spend in groups. In the early stages of the game (level 40 and below), it hovers at around 30%. Even if we assume players spend a fair amount of time crafting, selling goods on the auction house, etc., it is hard to see these activities accounting for 70% of the time spent in-game. It is only at level 56 and above that players spend the majority of their time in groups (probably raiding high-end instances). Moreover, players favor "soloable" classes (warriors, hunters) that, by design, survive mob encounters better in solo play - the more social classes (e.g. priests) that require a group to work well are among the least favored. Compounding the problem, and despite features like WoW’s "group xp bonus", grouping is an inefficient way to level, which naturally steers the more "hardcore" players away from groups (at least, in the early stages of the game).
Overall, this data indicates that instrumental group play in the context of quests might not be an important source of social interactions in WoW. How about guilds? Excluding level 1 characters, 62% of WoW’s players are in guilds. Interestingly however, 17.5% of them belong to a "one-person guild" - in other words, nothing more than a custom tag below their name (which, incidentally, says volume about the trouble players are willing to go through to customize their avatars). That leaves only 44.5% of players in guilds with at least 2 members. Moreover WoW’s guilds are fairly small (median size: 9) and very few grow beyond 35 members (90th percentile) - a kind of Dunbar Number for guilds.
More importantly, guilds are also very sparse social networks. Our analyses indicate that the average guild member in WoW spends little time with a large majority of his/her guildmates. Over a month, the average guild member is online 20 minutes or less with 80% of his/her guildmates. The same average member collaborates (in quests, etc.) with only 11% of his/her guildmates for more than 10 minutes over the same month. In other words, most guilds in WoW are not highly social and/or collaborative environments.
Considering all this, it is easy to wonder why WoW’s players spend so much time (more than 10 hours per week) in this game instead of a single-player RPG! To me, WoW illustrates how a large number (the majority?) of online gamers enjoy being "alone together." The social factor at work here clearly has little to do with direct interactions and camaraderie in the context of quest groups or guilds. Instead, it looks as if other players are mostly:
An audience (to showcase your latest "elite" gear and other accomplishments). A social presence (the constant flow of chat in the wide-reaching "general" channel, the movement of other avatars around you, make playing WoW somewhat analogous to reading a book in a densely populated café - while you may not necessarily choose to interact with the other patrons, the sense of being in a public social space can be attractive enough to conduct individual activities there). A source of spectacle and entertainment ("people watching" is fun in WoW, in part because Blizzard encouraged it by design with many humorous objects that can be appropriated by the players - the gnomes’ various trinkets with unpredictable effects, the infamous 20-lb catfish that can be used as a weapon, etc).
Does this mean that, to reach WoW’s scale and attract gamers as-yet unfamiliar with the genre, future MMOs should focus less on collaborative questing and other traditional techniques to encourage interactions, favoring instead "looser," more indirect forms of social experience? A "society of the spectacle," to use Guy Debord’s terminology? Or are there alternatives?
(P.S.: an expanded version of this analysis will appear in a CHI 2006 paper I’d be happy to send to interested readers).
Nicolas Ducheneaut on Feb 06, 2006 in Sociology | Permalink
Digg This | Save to del.icio.us
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c022953ef00d834516f1969e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "Alone Together" in World of Warcraft?:
» Alone Together from The Escapist Blog
PlayOn has been collecting data for a while now, and Nicolas Ducheneaut posted a very interesting analysis on Terra Nova. It basically concludes that most players in WoW tend to spend most of their time alone, playing through the game as a single-playe… [Read More]
Tracked on Feb 09, 2006 at 09:40
» Alone Together in World of Warcraft from Miscellaneous Flotch
Alone together in World of Warcraft: an interesting analysis of the social dynamics of this supposedly multiplayer game. This article argues that, largely, people choose t… [Read More]
Tracked on Feb 09, 2006 at 11:16
» Zusammen alleine from Die Todeskrallen
Spielen in einem MMO heisst Zusammen spielen - so denkt man. Ganz im Gegenteil! Das Blog Terra Nova ver?ffentlicht eine Untersuchung, die interessante Statistiken und Analysen zul??t.
Terra Nova behandelt die sozialen, ?konomischen, r… [Read More]
Tracked on Feb 10, 2006 at 09:10
» bad credit loan from loan personal
Loans Home Equity Loans - Home Mortgage Student Loans [Read More]
Tracked on May 27, 2006 at 19:58
» car loan from loan student
Loans Home Equity Loans - Home Mortgage Student Loans [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 04, 2006 at 22:13
» Robots Help Sick Kids Stay In School from are helping hospitalized
are helping hospitalized children keep up with classwork and classmates. [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 09, 2006 at 22:39
» New York Liberty game notes from 75, Liberty 60
The Liberty opened thesecond home game of the season leading the Connec… - WNBA New York Liberty [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 10, 2006 at 05:26
» Open-Xchange Server Wins ServerWatch Product Excellence Award from source collaboration
open source collaboration server. (PRWEB Jun 8, 2006) [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 11, 2006 at 14:23
» Number Of Children And Teens Treated With Antipsychotics Increases Sharply from increasing number
in the June issue of Archives of General Psychiatry, one of the JAMA/Archives journals. [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 12, 2006 at 16:09
» loan online from loan mortgage
Loans Home Equity Loans - Home Mortgage Student Loans [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 12, 2006 at 23:47
» Fewer Teens Report Risky Behavior from common in today’s
risky behaviors are less common in today’s high school students than in those 15 years earlier, according to a new CDC report. [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 13, 2006 at 07:30
» Freezing Eggs to Beat the Biological Clock from omen Holding
omen Holding Off Motherhood Looking for New Fertility Treatments [Read More]
Tracked on Jun 19, 2006 at 05:28
» UPC sets date for ‘triple play’ launch from the owner of
Ireland, the owner of NTL Ireland and Chorus, is to launch the first phase of its ‘triple play’ product in July. [Read More]
Tracked on Jul 01, 2006 at 01:52
» Estradiol ivf level. from Injectable estradiol with a prescription.
Estradiol levels. Diagnosis code for estradiol and progesterone. Estradiol dosages. Biodentical estradiol. Estradiol for less. Estradiol in men. Estradiol. [Read More]
Tracked on Aug 31, 2009 at 05:12
» Percocet. from Percocet dosage.
Percocet. Long term use of percocet. [Read More]
Tracked on Sep 03, 2009 at 08:19
» Effects of soma. from Soma cannabis.
Soma. Drug soma. [Read More]
Tracked on Sep 08, 2009 at 09:26
» Xanax addiction. from Xanax.
What happens when you crush xanax xr. Xanax no prescription. Xanax. Xanax online. Xanax lawsuits. Titel auteur datum xanax medication bmnwbbuk. [Read More]
Tracked on Sep 15, 2009 at 22:26
Comments "Alone Together" in World of Warcraft?
The "social factor" is often advanced to explain the popularity of MMOs: "it’s the people that are addictive, not the game." And indeed, social networks are essential components of the online gaming experience. Game designers build "virtual third places" to encourage interactions. Quality time in a MMO is time spent with others, be it raiding a dungeon in a group, socializing with bystanders in a cantina, or chatting with remote guildmates while exploring the wilderness on your own.
Or… is it? The data PlayOn has assembled from World of Warcraft challenges many of these assumptions. Could it be that a less, not more, social environment contributed to WoW’s success? Read on for more.
View the entire comment thread. Active Authors Bartle, Richard Bloomfield, Robert Burke, Timothy Castronova, Edward Combs, Nate Consalvo, Mia Damer, Bruce Ducheneaut, Nic Galarneau, Lisa Hunter, Dan Lastowka, Greg Lawley, Liz Malaby, Thomas Reynolds, Ren Ruberg, Bonnie Sellers, Mike Contributing Authors Book, Betsy
Dibbell, Julian
Fairfield, Joshua
Moore, Bob
Mulligan, Jessica
Nickell, Eric
Ondrejka, Cory
Steinkuehler, Constance
Taylor, TL
Williams, Dmitri
Yee, Nick
Yoon, Unggi
Past Guests Burgaard, Peder Chee, Florence Chesney, Thomas Corbit, Margaret Dornan, Jennifer Grace, Merci Victoria Hinn, Michelle Hughes, Ian Jinman, Andrew Lamont, Ian Lodder, Arno McGinley, Robert Nova, Nicolas Pearce, Celia Purbrick, Jim Reynolds, Roo Rickey, Dave Townsend Gard, Elizabeth Wallace, Mark Upcoming Conferences 01. 2009 March 23 – 27: GDC, San Francisco, CA, USA 02. 2009 April 24 – 25: Play-Machinima-Law, Stanford University,buy wow gold, CA, USA 03. 2009 July 27 - 29: FAVE 09, Berlin, Germany Collaborative Units Gamasutra
Gameology
Grand Text Auto
Joystick101
Kotaku
Penny Arcade
The Escapist
Virtual Cultures
Virtual Economy Research Network
Virtual Policy Network
Research Resource Rolodex Aleks Krotoski Alice Robison Alice Taylor Amy Bruckman Amy Jo Kim Anders Tychsen Anne Galloway Anne-Marie Schleiner Beth Noveck Brandon Rickman Brenda Laurel Chaim Gingold Chris Crawford Clay Shirky Clive Thompson Dan Norton David Kennerly David Thomas Dennis Jerz Elizabeth Reid Steere Eric Zimmerman Ernest Adams Espen Aarseth Gonzalo Frasca Gordon Calleja Greg Costikyan Hiroshi Yamaguchi Ian Reid J (aka DV) Jane McGonigal Janet Murray Jason Della Rocca Jason Rhody Jason Rutter Jay Bibby Jeffrey Bardzell Jesper Juul Jill Walker Julian Kücklich Jurie Horneman Kathryn Wright Krista Lee Malone Kurt Squire Lars Konzack Lauren Burka Lee Sheldon Lisbeth Klastrup Mark Bernstein Mary Flanagan Matthew Kirschenbaum Mirjam Eladhari Mizuko Ito Nick Montfort Nina Huntemann Peter Jenkins Raph Koster Robin Hunicke Ron Gilbert Ross Mayfield Sal Humphreys Sara Grimes Scott Jennings Scott Miller Scott Moore Scott Rettberg Shaowen Bardzell Shuen-shing Lee Sir Bruce Steven Shaviro Stuart Moulthrop Susan Crawford Susana Tosca Thom Gillespie Tish Shute Tom Coates Torill Mortensen Wagner James Au William Huber Subscribe to this blog’s feed
相关的主题文章：
April 9th, 2010 at 6:54 am
[...] Maps, Quests, Items, NPCs, Mobs and more for WoW - [...]
April 9th, 2010 at 6:54 am
[...] Maps, Quests, Items, NPCs, Mobs and more for WoW - [...]